Follow on Google News
Florida & Cedar Key News

Cedar Key · Levy County · The Nature Coast

Williston Firefighters File No-Confidence Declaration Against Mayor Over Fire Chief Plan

A proposal to have the police chief oversee Williston Fire Rescue was dropped over dual-office-holding concerns, but not before firefighters and residents confronted Mayor Charles Goodman at the Nov. 3 council meeting.

A withdrawn proposal, a lasting rift

Williston Fire Rescue firefighters have formally declared “no confidence” in Mayor Charles Goodman, escalating a dispute that began when Goodman floated putting Police Chief Mike Rolls in charge of the fire department. The plan was withdrawn after the city attorney flagged legal problems, but the fallout played out in public at the Nov. 3 Williston City Council meeting, according to WUFT News.

Fire Chief Lamar Stegall, who is retiring Dec. 31 after more than 30 years in the fire service, said he learned of the proposed change in a meeting, not before it. “I was called into a meeting, and I was told this was going to happen,” Stegall told WUFT. Goodman said in an email his goal was a smooth transition after Stegall’s departure, and that he told Stegall directly he intended to replace him, citing his authority under the city charter.

Why the plan died

The proposal unraveled over a legal issue, not public pressure alone. Goodman said the city attorney identified “dual office holders” problems, a legal doctrine, cited by the state attorney, barring one person from holding two public offices simultaneously. That conflict applied to having the police chief also run the fire department, and Goodman said it drove his decision to withdraw the idea. He said the city is now looking at other, unspecified options to prepare the department for the future.

Firefighters go on record

During public comment, firefighter paramedic Cody Murphy read a written declaration of no confidence signed by members of Williston Fire Rescue. The document alleged intimidation, hostility and an unprofessional work environment in Goodman’s dealings with city employees, and said the mayor repeatedly characterized Stegall as “the enemy” while Stegall tried to explain department operations. Firefighters also said there had been behind-the-scenes efforts to remove Stegall before his planned retirement.

The declaration asked the council to formally acknowledge the concerns, consider an independent investigation or administrative review, and set clearer expectations for how elected officials communicate with city staff. Stegall said he had no advance knowledge of the declaration but backed his colleagues speaking out: “I support them to fight for what they believe in.”

Residents outside the city weigh in

The controversy also drew in people who live beyond Williston’s limits but rely on the department for emergency response. Jimbo Williams told council members he wants a chief “that Lamar Stegall trained from here right on up” to respond if his house catches fire, and warned that leadership turmoil could leave trucks without qualified drivers. Angela Yancey said her trust in the department rests on Stegall’s personal familiarity with residents and their homes, telling officials she had never met them before.

The police chief and mayor respond

Rolls told the council he never wanted to take over the fire department and was following orders when the idea was discussed. He said only three people were present when the plan was raised, himself, Goodman and a human resources representative, and disputed any suggestion he and Goodman conspired to seize control of the department. “All it’s doing is creating chaos,” Rolls said, adding that the dispute was “destroying the whole city.”

Goodman said he was trying to understand fire department operations and ensure continuity after Stegall’s exit, noting departments “are supposed to be intergenerational.” He apologized to anyone who felt offended but did not retract his underlying push to plan for new leadership.

What’s next

No vote or formal council action on the no-confidence declaration was reported. The city has not detailed what alternative plan it will pursue before Stegall’s Dec. 31 retirement, leaving the succession question, and the rift between the mayor and his fire department, unresolved heading into December.

Sources