Lawsuit Over Chattahoochee Hospital Death Tests Oversight at State Agency That Reaches Every County
A Gadsden County lawsuit accusing DCF and Florida State Hospital of failing to supervise patients raises questions that apply to the statewide system Levy County residents can also be committed into.
A death inside a state-run hospital
A lawsuit filed in Gadsden County Circuit Court accuses Florida’s Department of Children and Families and Florida State Hospital in Chattahoochee of failing to protect a patient who was strangled to death by another patient in February, according to WCJB TV20, citing reporting from WCTV. The suit was brought by the parents of Nicholas Lombardi, who had schizophrenia and had been a patient at the state-run psychiatric hospital.
Police arrested Chase Johnson in connection with the killing. According to arrest papers cited in the report, Johnson told investigators he strangled Lombardi, that the two had never argued, and that he acted because “voices told him to do it.” Johnson has pleaded not guilty and is being tried, according to court records referenced in the report.
What the lawsuit alleges
The family’s attorney, Nicholas Spetsas, said the complaint centers on a basic failure of supervision. “Staff failed to do the basics, supervise residents, monitor them and separate people who posed a known danger to others,” Spetsas said, according to the report. He said hospital staff did not discover Lombardi’s death until after it occurred.
Thomas Lombardi, the victim’s father, described the phone call notifying him of his son’s death as something “beyond what I can describe.” He said his son had shown signs of coping with his illness before his death cut that progress short.
The report states DCF has not yet issued a response to the lawsuit, and that WCTV had reached out to the agency for comment without hearing back as of publication.
Why a Chattahoochee case matters on the Nature Coast
Florida State Hospital is operated by DCF, the same state agency that oversees mental health commitments, licensing and crisis services statewide, including in Levy County and across north central Florida. Civil and forensic psychiatric patients committed through Florida’s courts can be placed in DCF-run facilities regardless of where they live, which means the staffing, supervision and safety practices named in this lawsuit are not confined to Gadsden County. They describe the same statewide system that local families, law enforcement and the courts rely on when someone here is committed for psychiatric treatment.
Spetsas said the family’s goal extends beyond the courtroom. “What they want is for no other family to ever get that phone call,” he said. “We could see policies change. We could see staffing change, and we could see lives getting saved.” Whether that happens will depend on how DCF responds to the suit and whether any findings prompt changes to patient-monitoring practices at facilities the agency runs across the state.
What to watch
No ruling has been issued, and DCF has not filed a public response as of this report. Florida & Cedar Key News will note any court filings, agency statements or policy changes that follow, particularly any that touch DCF’s broader psychiatric hospital system serving counties beyond Gadsden, including this region. Readers with experience navigating Florida’s civil commitment or state hospital system, including in Levy County, can contact this newsroom with documented concerns.